I decided to give it a go. 11 years after they released the album, I decided to give St Anger by Metallica another go. They deserve all the divisive reviews they got when they released this album, and Im here trying to break it down just what they got wrong and right.
Firstly the sound. I know they went for a stripped down sound with no dubbing or mixing but at the very least they could have made it sound less like jamming in a garage and closer to a stage / soundcheck quality.
Lars Ulrich has always tried to innovate his drum sound, but on this album his drums grate in your face constantly. It sounds like his drum kit consists of a cow bell and a trash can. It takes a immense effort to overcome this.
Guitarwise (and bass wise too) it sounds fresh, energetic and raw. It sounds like a band working out the demos just before they enter the studio proper and the final practise sessions before they move in and begin recording. I think the rejection of wanting to have guitar solos for any of the songs is a brave move, but closer to what a band would sound like in the raw. It wouldnt have hurt for Kirk Hammet or James Hetfield to have improvised a guitar solo jam over the top now and then. Surprisingly for a album with no solos, some of the songs can go on for a considerable amount of time, over 8 minutes in places.
The time between Reload and St Anger was a long time, time enough to have worked out 2 albums worth of material including solos and mixing, so to my ears and many other Metallica fans this sounds unfinished incomplete and unsatisfying. But look beneath the rough exterior and you will find some solid guitar work and more.
The more in this instance is an incredible improvement with James Hetfield's vocal ability. He sings now with far more emotion that he has done, and is closer to the style from the Load and Reload albums, especially on the title track.
Metallica (i.e. Lars and James) have done some dickhead things in their career, drugs, tattoos, alcohol, pro-gun lobby, Napster but to quote James "I'm madly in Anger with you.". But we, the fans are mad because deep down we really do love them, care about them and want them not to make arseholes of themselves.
Lets see how my opinion of Death Magnetic changes and then I may feel brave enough to try Lulu.
No comments:
Post a Comment